Questions to Master Deshimaru

Question

Dogen criticized. Masters are always criticizing each other. What do you think about criticism?

Answer

To progress, we need discussion. Personal criticism is bad; in fact, it is forbidden. But discussions of different schools, doctrines, philosophies, are necessary. Sometimes, a genuine criticism is beneficial. I like to hear real criticism; it makes me progress. Dogen's criticism of Rinzai was genuine. And if you want to find true Zen, self-criticism is necessary. Not egotistical criticism, but the means of finding what is best for oneself, true religion.